This was a session at Sol 2014.
Participants
Discussion
Out on the lake
- Eric: I’d prefer to be out in the sticks
- Ben: I think we should be near a major city to find allies in all the circles of our Venn diagram
- Eric: I agree that the first SolSeed commune needs to be urban for recruitment, but I envision multiple communes in all kinds of places
- Shelley: I want it to be a beautiful place, which is easier when it’s farther from a city
- Patrick: I think you’ll need an urban area to have access to technology
Back at the campsite
- Ted: The Timeless Way of Building talks about how to make spaces that have an undefinable quality of “aliveness”
- Ben: But how do you measure that?
- Brandon: Spaces that have this quality would be used more
- Ted: The book has patterns like the “window place,” where people sit in such a way as to include both inside and outside-the-window space in their perception
- Another, clearly testable pattern is the “intimacy gradient”: the most private/intimate spaces should be farthest from the front door
- Brandon: I feel we’ve accomplished “aliveness” in our back garden
- The book talks about going to the target property and feeling out where things should go, rather than just looking at street grids
- Ted: I cofounded a housing co-op in Chicago, buying a building with 7 other people
- We didn’t have the funds to reshape the space the way we’d like, but it’s still a great place
- Ted: I lived at Daybreak Cohousing in several configurations (with a partner, with a roommate, in a rental space)
- The main problem at Daybreak was that the whole thing fell apart financially
- The architecture was fascinating, focusing on connection and community rather than privacy, but relationships themselves are more important than architecture
- Patrick: I visit with a friend every week even though he lives a half-hour bike ride away
- Ted: People often connect through necessity of helping each other
- Brandon: People you see a lot become people you see even more
- Ted: If you build community with the people who are already around you in a neighborhood, that’s an organic way to do it that I’m increasingly fond of
- In intentional communities you have intense inward focus that excludes connection with outside neighbors to some degree
- Of course, the advantage of intentional community is a built-in expectation of relationships with internal neighbors
- But I’d want a long process of establishment to ensure a new intentional community was built on a solid basis of good relationships; I think SolSeed is doing this very well
- I love my current neighbors in my ordinary neighborhood
- Brandon: How much of that connection came from your boys?
- Ted: All of it, although it’s not just about age/school; we’re also friends with the older woman next door
- Patrick: We have a similar experience; no longer making new connections with neighbors since I grew up
- Ted: Cohousing is the worst of both worlds; no vision other than “we want to live in community”
- Take a bunch of introverts who don’t know each other and don’t know their current neighbors and throw them in a building together
- Brandon (much later): Like being at a social event at a business convention, vs. an event with family and friends
- This problem probably gets much less severe in older communities, once people have bandwidth to get to know each other
- Ben: Was Daybreak like that?
- Ted: We had a 10-point vision, but it was only aspirational and didn’t make any real difference
- Now that I’ve tried a bunch of different stuff, I’m a lot less clear on what’s best
- Brandon: We should avoid “building a box and filling it”
- Lord of the Rings metaphor: Don’t build giant centrally-planned dwarven cities; build more like the Shire, where it looks like growth can happen more organically at the “edges”
- Ted: But in an urban environment, organic growth is stymied by the fact that houses only go up for sale very rarely
- Brandon: Trying to build community and failing can be harmful to relationships
- We set up a Saturday school with Meg and Lyric, sort of “SolSeed lite,” and when it didn’t work, our relationship collapsed
- Ted: I know three families that get together around gaming, which is low-risk, low-commitment, and therefore it’s hard to imagine a dramatic breakup
- Ben: Interestingly, Lion is doing a lot of game nights recently, but I don’t think he’s doing it to be low-risk
- Patrick, Brandon: Maybe it’s like casual dating, a first contact that can become deeper later
- Brandon: I get the sense that like me, Ted is a “signer-upper”
- Ted: In college, I noticed that I was involved in lots of things but my friends were only involved in one thing: each other
- Ben: I get the sense that that kind of intense single focus is what Lion is looking for
- Patrick: My friends and I are somewhat like that; if I don’t wake up early enough to go to our regular meet, they’ll usually drive over to my place
- Ted: I’ve always been aiming to make the world a better place
- Ben: Maybe that kind of person is more likely to be involved in multiple groups
- Brandon: But SolSeed has been a constant center for me as my other groups shift, because in other groups, if the goal stops being important to the participants, it just ends
- Ben: But it seems like you’re willing to let the SolSeed movement die if something else expresses its vision and principles better
- Brandon: Well, right now my ability to shape SolSeed is such that in the near term, there’s little risk that it will stop expressing who I am
- On the other hand, I helped found the Buckman Neighborhood Picnic and am now moving away from it; likewise with Recent Changes Camp; they were temporary expressions of my “bring life” values, while SolSeed embodies those values themselves
- Brandon: I believe that planning is futile (because of the Singularity), but practice is not
- Ben: But planning an intentional community is what we were talking about
- Brandon: I think planning is a good practice
- Ted: But plans are useless
- Ted: We have a single One-Page Plan for our family and our business, and had a difficult time filling in our BHAG, so we filled in a draft answer that seemed unrelated to our near-term plans, but it enabled me to do a workshop in Detroit later because it fit the BHAG
- This ability to grab BHAG-related opportunities happens with my clients as well
- Eric: The important part of planning is getting clear on your values; that’s why I made the snap decision to join SolSeed
- Ben: What counts as practice?
- Brandon: Practice is about growing your wisdom about some topic; it gives you a deep level of understanding of how something works, so you don’t need rules to follow